Executive Recruiter Critically Needed for New Portco

Firm needed executive recruiter to place CEO with industry expertise

Having recently invested in a sector for the first time, a PE firm came to us with an urgent need for an executive recruiter. Knowing that they needed to place an industry expert as CEO in their new power solutions portfolio company, the firm was in need of a specialized executive recruiter that had experience and deep network connections in the nuanced sector. Ultimately, the PE firm was seeking an executive recruiter that could quickly place an experienced CEO with a background in the power solutions market in their new portfolio company.

BluWave identified PE-grade executive recruiter from pre-vetted network

Leveraging our founder’s 20 years in private equity, we have extensive frameworks for assessing PE-grade executive recruiter needs. BluWave utilizes technology, data, and human ingenuity to pre-map, assess, monitor, and maintain deep pools of specialized executive recruiters across various industries that uniquely meet the private equity standard. We interviewed the PE firm to understand their specific key criteria, and then quickly connected the client with two select pre-vetted executive recruiters from our invitation-only Intelligent Network that fit their exacting needs.

Firm engaged provider and successfully recruited CEO

The PE firm selected their ideal recruiter who started sourcing candidates immediately. With their deep network connections and intimate understanding of the industry, the recruiter was able to identify exact-fit candidates faster than generalist recruiters the PE firm had previously used. The executive search firm successfully recruited a CEO for the portfolio company who had decades of experience in the power solutions industry, prior business experience as an executive within a PE-backed company, and demonstrated financial acumen in similarly-sized companies.

PE Firm in Need of Short-Term Resource

PE firm needed short-term resources after unexpected loss

A private equity firm in our network unexpectedly lost two mid-level investment team members within a few weeks of each other. In order to avoid missing out on active deal opportunities, the PE firm needed to quickly find a short-term resource who could meet its team standards and bridge the gap while it searched for a full-time hire.

Bluwave connected firm with top-tier candidates

With our extensive private equity knowledge, rooted in our founder’s 20 years of PE industry experience, we use time-tested frameworks to assess PE-grade investment professionals for interim work opportunities with our clients. We quickly identified several candidates whose experience matched the exacting needs of the PE firm based on specific criteria outlined during the initial assessment.

Client engaged candidates and found stability during the transition

Within two weeks, a top-tier MBA with four years of relevant PE experience joined the team. The independent consultant was integrated into the core team quickly to ensure that projects stayed on course. He stayed for three months, giving the PE firm client stability and a much-needed resource while it searched for a full-time candidate.

How We Did it: Private Equity Associate Case Study

With our extensive private equity knowledge, we use time-tested frameworks to assess PE-grade investment professionals for interim work opportunities with our clients. This means when clients have a need, we can move swiftly to connect them with viable, third-party resources. When a private equity fund in our network unexpectedly lost two mid-level investment team members within a few weeks of each other, they needed to quickly find a short-term resource who could meet its team standards and bridge the gap while it searched for a full-time hire. 

For the full story, read the case study here. 

BluWave Insights: How the Agile Workforce is Impacting the Economy

Many hiring managers report that they face a talent shortage, which is why the agile workforce – independent professionals hired on a project-by-project basis – is only going to become more critical in the coming years. In my first article for Toolbox HR, a new platform for executives to learn about everything from cybersecurity trends to the nuances of “people and talent,” I explore topics related to this workforce evolution. 

What is the agile workforce?
Simply put, it’s flexible, filled with experts, and moves quickly to help companies address a wide range of talent issues. Companies can access industry- and project-specific expertise with the flexibility to quickly and efficiently adapt to rapidly changing economic circumstances – crystalized in the massive economic fallout of COVID-19. Agile workers are becoming more important all the time.  

In the article, I address the following: 

  1. Finding Professionals With the Right Skills 
  2. Why Agile Workforce Isn’t the Gig Economy 
  3. Making the Most of the Agile Workforce 

Click here to read the full article, and please feel free to share/amplify to spread the word!  

How We Did It: Cost Reduction Case Study 

PE funds across a broad spectrum of industries often approach us with specific, episodic needs. Our first step for matching them with best-in-class, third party resources is to understand the nuances and unique challenges they face. When a private equity firm acquired a leading plastics company that designed and manufactured innovative plastic-injection-molded products, the firm believed there was room for improvement and cost reductions in the company’s supply contracts. We quickly matched these criteria to the pre-vetted candidates from our invitation-only network, rooted in our founder’s 20 years of PE industry experience.

For the full story, read the case study here.

State of PE: An Interview with Huron Capital’s Gretchen Perkins

Private equity is a widely misunderstood industry – from the common belief that Private Equity firms snatch up companies just to strip them down and sell them to the lack of awareness about the pivotal role PE plays in the modern economy. Gretchen Perkins is a partner who focuses on business development at Huron Capital, and there’s nobody better to correct the mistaken assumptions about her industry and give us a glimpse into the current state of PE. Gretchen was kind enough to answer a few of our questions about the state of her industry, the effects of COVID-19 on her firm, and what she envisions for the future. 

Sean Mooney: Tell me a bit about Huron Capital’s investment focus. 

Gretchen PerkinsWe’re a middle market PE firm that implements a buy and build strategy to grow businesses. We focus on business services, consumer goods, and specialized industrial companies in the United States and Canada. We have both a control buyout strategy and a non-control equity strategy.  

SM: What are a few of the biggest myths about the PE industry? 

GP: The single biggest myth about PE firms is that we buy companies and sell them in pieces to make our money. The PE industry is a significant job creator across the U.S. – over the past ten years, PE-backed businesses created more jobs and secured more sales than other companies. There’s a reason college endowments, pension funds, insurance companies, foundations, and nonprofits invest in PE – it has been the single leading asset class over the past 20 years. There are billions of dollars flowing into PE because of the returns and the fact that the industry creates more value and is less volatile than other investment vehicles. 

Despite the perception that PE firms always take over and try to sell companies quickly, the PE industry plays a long-term game. Firms generally want business owners to stay and maintain equity in the business – they don’t just take over.   We want to make the companies substantially better over time because it’s the best interest of both our firm and our stakeholders. 

SM: What was your firm’s initial response to COVID-19? 

GP: We acted several weeks before everything started shutting down to increase support for our portfolio companies. For example, we developed a Rapid Response Playbook focused on the implementation of safety protocols and developing guidelines for remote work. There are 7,000 employees at our portfolio companies, and their safety is our top priority.  

SM: How do the prospects for recovery look?  

GP: When the crisis hit, we immediately started doing 13-week cash flow forecasts, and we’ve discovered that things aren’t as bad as we initially thought it could have been. Now we’re focused on implementing our Restart Playbook, which is designed to take a close look at business operations across our portfolio and help companies emerge from the crisis even stronger and more adaptable. We’re doing everything we can to help our portfolio companies navigate COVID-19 and the economic aftermath, but our management teams are rising to the occasion. This should serve as a reminder that in the current state of PE, firms are more interested in finding effective partners they can work with to build great companies over the long run than ineffectively micromanaging the companies in their portfolios.  

SM: What types of businesses are you focused on investing in and growing now?  

GPWe’re looking at add-on acquisitions to companies that can thrive during the crisis – insurance companies, for instance. We are also looking into food and beverage businesses that have proven to be COVID-19 resistant. But what we’re most interested in are companies that have solid leadership teams and growth potential – these are the partners that will help us move into the post-COVID-19 era in a stronger position than ever.

How We Did It: Executive Search Case Study

Finding specialized executive search firms is an area PE funds often seek our assistance, because instead of spending countless hours trying to find the right fit we can quickly match the funds with a series of vetted candidates. So, when our PE fund client acquired a founder-owned business that provides services to the niche power solutions market, they needed deep network connections beyond its immediate purview to source a highly capable CEO with industry experience. 

For the full story, read the case study here.

Industry Insights: An Interview with ParkerGale’s Devin Mathews

This is an unprecedented time for private equity firms and their portfolio companies. As the economy begins to show signs of a tenuous post-COVID-19 recovery, there is no telling how the business landscape will be impacted. But one thing is clear: PE will be a major factor in the recovery. Devin Mathews is a partner at ParkerGale, and he generously took the time to discuss his firm, perceptions of the PE industry, and what investment trends we should be keeping an eye on right now. 

Sean Mooney: Tell me about ParkerGale’s history and investment philosophy. 

Devin Mathews: ParkerGale was founded in 2014, though the founding team worked together running the technology group at another private equity firm. We only do tech buyouts (not venture capital or growth equity) and always take a majority control position. We only buy in two ways: directly from bootstrapped founders or as carve out divisions from larger companies. Both of these strategies have similar dynamics – good businesses that need some care and attention. We focus on owners who are at an inflection point with all their wealth tied up in the business – we help them greatly reduce their personal financial risk and take their businesses to the next level. 

SM: Why would an owner want to partner with ParkerGale?  

DM: Quality, not quantity, is our ambition. At the end of the day, founders bring us in because they believe we’re going to respect the businesses they’ve built. We’ll change things, but the employees will still feel like it’s a great place to work. We place a heavy emphasis on culture and developing people at our portfolio companies, and even though our expectations are high, we recognize that we have to provide the necessary resources to meet those expectations. 

SM: What are a few of the biggest myths about PE? 

DM: For starters, not all PE firms are created equal. There are different types of PE firms out there: some are more transactional, while others are more hands-on and operational to help companies build long-term success.  

Also, it’s important to recognize that private equity is the economy – it’s not a niche asset class anymore. There are twice as many private equity-backed companies as public companies. This is all the more reason why PE firms have to focus on improving the image of the industry and showing others that our success as an industry is determined by the long term success of the companies we own. This industry cannot thrive if our companies fail.  

As an industry, our reputation isn’t great. People sometimes expect all of us to be MBA jerks, with low EQ and high intensity. While much of that is well-deserved, we try to show people we’re human, empathic, and prepared to listen. At ParkerGale, we talk a lot about vulnerability, transparency, and trust. That’s really the only way to get results in our experience. 

SM: How has COVID-19 impacted your firm?  

DM: We are all getting older around here and have invested during booms and busts before. We all subscribe to the great Howard Marks quote that “you can’t predict – you can only prepare.” So we don’t make predictions. We just get up every day and execute alongside our management teams.   

SM: What types of businesses are you focused on investing in now?  

DM: We look for software companies that are hard to hurt – that means they have sticky products, no customer concentration, no vendor concentration, and good profit margins. They’re also in segments of the market where VCs aren’t pointing their money cannons, which usually ends up poorly. When we get involved, the companies are customer-centric and profitable, but may not necessarily be doing the things they need to do to secure long-term viability. There are tens of thousands of companies in North America that fit our criteria, and we need to invest in one or two per year. We operate at the small end of the market – we’re providing the first institutional capital that any of these companies have had.  

SM: What’s your take on the future of PE investment?  

DM: Within the next six months, will founders say “I’m too old for this sh*t” and want to sell even if it’s at a price less than the top of the market? Or will they wait for the market to come back enough to get them the price they need to walk away? Just imagine you’re a founder in your sixties and you’ve been through way too many ups and downs already. Do you have the stomach to hang on a few years or is it time to find the right partner that helps you walk away and enjoy retirement? My sense is that it will be a mix of the two, but as I said earlier, we don’t try to predict. So we’ll just prepare for whatever comes our way. 

How to find and leverage expertise

The COVID-19 pandemic won’t last forever, and companies need to be thinking about how to best position themselves to not only maintain their operations, but also seize upon opportunities and prepare for an uncertain future. This means they’ll have to be agile, getting the right people with the right skills at the right time.  

Our economy is more dependent on expertise than ever before – a fact that’s even clearer amid this crisis. A 2019 study conducted by the Society for Human Resource Management found that 83 percent of hiring managers “had trouble recruiting suitable candidates,” 75 percent of whom attributed this problem to a skills shortage in the workforce.  

The recovery from COVID-19 is going to require a lot of innovative thinking, which means contributions from a broad range of experts in many different fields. But expertise is scarce – especially for companies with limited resources. Experts are always in high demand, even more so when companies begin rebuilding after a shock like COVID-19. Companies have little margin for error and they’re taking a hard look at their processes and personnel. That’s why we’ll soon see a spike in the need for on-demand expertise across a wide range of disciplines. 

Here are a few strategies for finding experts and making the most of their skills. 

Know what you’re looking for.
First, 
your business needs to take the time to thoughtfully define what it needs. For each role, systematically build scorecards outlining what expertise is required for each initiative. This scorecard should measure functional experience, industry experience, budget, values, and the ability to learn and change. For example, if a food manufacturing company is hiring an interim CFO, a candidate with years of manufacturing experience is not enough. The company should look for a candidate who has worked in the food industry, and who has a track record of successfully managing crises and other fluid situations.  

Know where to look.
To find experts like this, 
you could start by canvassing your personal and professional networks with a specific “ask,” and be specific about your key criteria, timeframe, and budget. These constraints and goals will guide which kind of expert you’re looking for. In some cases, you want someone who can mobilize teams rapidly or manage a fast-moving crisis. In others (some forms of product development, for instance), you want someone who’s more deliberate and meticulous.  

Use intelligent networks.
Intelligent expertise networks are only going to become more important in the coming years as the need for on-demand skills jumps, availability becomes scarce, and margins for error decline.
 Naturally, firm like BluWave with deep industry relationships, proprietary datasets, and pre-vetted networks of private equity-grade resources is going to yield faster, more optimal results.  

Explore the alternative workforce.
According to a
2019 report from Deloitte, companies are leveraging alternative workers to address their expertise needs across a wide array of positions. Traditionally, most companies use the alternative workforce for highly specialized technical needs like I.T. However, the employment of alternative workers is rapidly spreading to other areas like sales, marketing, finance, and operations.  

Focus on integrating alternative workers and developing their skills.
Despite the surging demand for alternative workers, only 8 percent of companies report that they have “established processes to manage and develop alternative workforce sources.” The alternative workforce offers access to a growing and sophisticated talent pool, but employers need to develop the resources necessary to successfully draw upon this pool.  

Companies need to think of the on-demand alternative workforce just like they think about their full-time workforce. Define what is necessary to perform well in each role. Recruit candidates who have the specific expertise you require. Hold alternative workers and their managers accountable for results. At the end of the contract, both the employer and the alternative worker should evaluate whether a longer term, full-time relationship would be mutually beneficial.  

The economy is only becoming more interconnected and complex, which makes expertise vital. That’s why companies have to understand what expertise means to them, where it can be found, and how to use their knowledge and talent as effectively as possible.  

A version of this post originally appeared as part of the Forbes Business Council.

OODA Loop Offers a Solid Framework for Agile, Fast-Moving Companies

When I left my partner position at a PE fund to start BluWave, I sought an operating framework to help us build the company in an agile and customer-centric way. I embraced a model conceived by Air Force Colonel John Boyd called the OODA Loop (Observe, Orient, Decide, Act). This framework has been extremely helpful as we’ve grown to serving more than 350 PE funds in a short period of time. Now more than ever, we have found it to be invaluable as we navigate the uncertain world that has emerged since COVID arrived. Here’s how you can use the OODA loop in your business: 

Observe:
Get actionable data. One relatively inexpensive approach to gathering the right information is the use of a PE-grade voice of the customer firm to actively talk with your customers. As the economy reopens, ask your customers about the progress of their recovery and what products you should lead with. It’s amazing what customers will tell you if you ask. It’s also crucial to clean your data – we’re equipping portcos with interim data-oriented financial planning and analysis teams that can conduct a sprint in order to make data actionable. 

Orient:
Synthesize your observations. Many portcos we support are using PE market due diligence groups to assess competitive landscapes and propose potential courses of action. This is a way to repurpose an existing tool to improve probabilities of success and ROI. We’re also helping a lot of companies rapidly deploy data integration, visualization, and analytical resources to make informed decisions. If you haven’t used these resources yet, now is the time.  

Decide:
This is up to you and your team. The only advice I have here is to get buy-in from your team, as well as your board (for the bigger stuff). This is also a great time to question sacred cows, take a close look at SKUs, make your operations more efficient, etc. Never waste a crisis. 

Act:
It’s time to get going. After collecting hard data, forming conclusions about it, and making decisions with your team, now is the time to make a move. This is where it’s essential to be as adaptable as possible – the road back to Rome is not going to be straight. Be as justintime with your resources as possible.  It’s a great time to start using variable resources (aka the “alternative workforce”) to get things done more efficiently and effectively. 

Right after you act, immediately begin the OODA loop again. The most successful companies will be the ones that are agile and diligent during this chaotic and unpredictable time.

Research Finds PE-backed Companies More Resilient Than Others During Economic Contractions

Although states and businesses are beginning to reopen amid progress in the fight against COVID-19, the economic fallout has been devastating. Over the past nine weeks, almost 40 million Americans have filed for unemployment while the unemployment rate reached almost 15 percent in April – a number that has steadily increased since then. The private equity industry plays a substantial role in the U.S. Economy.  This raises the question: How is the PE industry equipped to support an economic recovery after such a massive shock?

One way to answer this question is to take a look at how PE-backed companies performed during the global recession in the late 2000s. A 2017 paper published by the National Bureau of Economic Research found that PE-backed companies were more resilient and rebounded more quickly than their non-PE-backed peers during the crisis, which offers hope for our economy today. Here are the top takeaways from that report:

  1. During the last Great Recession, private equity backed companies were able to make greater investments supporting their recovery than non-PE-backed companies. Their average quarterly business investment volume was between 5 and 6 percent greater, an effect that’s “not only statistically significant, but also large in economic magnitude.” PE-backed companies maintained this higher level of investment after the crisis.
  2. PE-backed companies had access to more debt and equity capital than their non-backed peers, by 4 and 2 percentage points, respectively. Meanwhile, the “cost of debt, measured by interest expense over total debt, was relatively lower for PE-backed companies during the crisis.” The researchers partly attribute these observations to the fact that private equity firms have strong relationships with lending institutions, which gives them more access to credit. PE investment also “did not lead to a low quality or excessively risky projects.”
  3. PE-backed companies that were more likely to face financial constraints during the recession (as indicated by factors such as their dependence on outside financing and their “pre-crisis leverage”) were especially likely to benefit from PE investment. Overall, the researchers write, “Private equity firms alleviated financing constraints of portfolio companies during the financial crisis, allowing them to invest more when credit markets were frozen and economic uncertainty high.”
  4. PE-backed companies saw “greater growth in their stock of assets in the years after the crisis” and actually increased market share during the recession: “In the crisis period,” the researchers write, “PE-backed companies experienced an 8 percent increase in market share relative to the control group.”
  5. PE-backed companies were comparatively seen as more attractive businesses by would be suitors after the recession.  The study found PE-backed companies were 30 percent more likely to be successfully acquired in the post-crisis period. Moreover,

At BluWave, we are already starting to see history repeat itself.  Our clients are moving at a rapid pace in support of the resurgence of their portfolio companies.  We are witnessing each of the elements of the above occurring in real time once again.  Moreover, we are seeing innovative applications of technology and business processes that we’ve never observed before.

While no two recessions are the same, the report suggests that PE-backed companies have several advantages as we navigate another severe economic downturn.  Private equity backed companies will have greater access to capital (at a lower cost) which will allow them to strategically invest more than their non-PE-backed peers and in turn support a faster economic recovery in the United States.

What We See Now: Post-COVID Strategy

As Yogi Berra once said: “The future ain’t what it used to be.”

Those words ring particularly true now, as everyone—from investors and business owners to teachers and healthcare workers—transition to living in a world with COVID-19. The numbers are in, and realistically this isn’t going away any time soon.

The good news is that, while the not so great cards have been dealt, we’re starting to see people embrace our new reality and play the hand. In turn, we’re seeing some amazing proactivity and innovation occurring within our 350 private equity fund customer base.

Here are a few things we’re seeing now:

#1 – CREATIVE INVESTMENT
As we all know, investors are practical optimists. They want to invest and are adapting to help companies succeed. We’re seeing equity investors get creative with where and how they play in the capital structure. We’re also seeing a lot of proactive market mapping repurposing commercial diligence firms to identify unseen opportunities so our clients can do their best to make things happen—if by sheer will.

#2 – TECHNOLOGY ADOPTION
The private equity industry is quickly catching up with proactive adoption of technology. One investment bank we work with is using drones and smart phones to conduct virtual site tours. We’re receiving significant inbounds for data visualization and collaboration resources. In many cases, our clients are sharing that they are seeing productivity actually go up (until 5:00 p.m., when we start getting overrun by virtual happy hours!).

#3 – CLEAN DATA FOCUSED
The victors will be those who are most agile. To be agile, you have to be able to see ahead, which requires clean data. We’re getting all sorts of requests for FP&A resources to clean and align disparate data sets so management teams can pivot as quickly as possible. We’re also seeing growing adoption of novel cloud tools to seamlessly stitch ERP and related datasets together versus embarking on risky ERP implementations.

#4 – LOCATION IS KEY
As flying still poses risks, many organizations are looking to engage variable resources that are geographically proximate to their portco locations. While working virtually is still the norm, physical presence will ultimately be required as companies begin to open up. If possible, make sure your variable resources are within a drive of your portcos. All of our resources are geo-tagged for this purpose.

Before the novel coronavirus reached our shores, we were receiving 30 inbound projects a week from our PE clients. Three weeks later, we saw two projects in a week come in. After a brief pause, now our phone is ringing off the hook again. It’s been amazing to see the tenacity, grit, and action that is occurring in PE across multiple fronts.

Please stay tuned-in to BluWave for “what’s next” and, in the meantime, keep up the good fight.