Private Equity's Industrial Rebound with MiddleGround's John Stewart
EPISODE 157
Episode Description
John Stewart, Founding and Managing Partner of MiddleGround Capital, returns to the Karma School of Business podcast to walk through the most volatile five years of his career in industrial investing. He traces the COVID-19 bullwhip, from $11 trillion of global stimulus to inflated inventory, destocking and $500 billion in write-offs, and explains why it hit manufacturers harder than 2008. John then explains why the cycle has turned, with PMI positive in Q1 2026, reshoring and defense spending driving demand, restored tax incentives reopening M&A, and owner-operators bringing businesses to market. His advice to operators is blunt, automate now, and he shows how AI is already reshaping his own portfolio. Press play.
Episode Highlights
- 2:50 - Why the COVID PMI collapse ran deeper than the global financial crisis
- 6:00 - The bullwhip effect: 24% costlier inventory, destocking, and $500B in write-offs
- 22:00 - Q1 2026 brings the first positive PMI in North America and Europe in years
- 24:50 - Defense quotes jump from 5% to 35% at a motorsport transmission maker
- 34:10 - How restored interest deductibility and 100% bonus depreciation reopened M&A
- 46:45 - John's advice to operators: automate the plant or risk not being around in five years
- 50:50 - How one portfolio company built its own CRM with Claude
For more on MiddleGround Capital, visit: https://middleground.com/
For more on John Stewart, visit: https://www.linkedin.com/in/johnstewartky
For more on BluWave, visit: https://www.bluwave.net/
Transcript
Sean Mooney: [00:00:00] Welcome to the Karma School of Business, a podcast about the private equity industry, business best practices, and real-time trends. I'm Sean Mooney, BluWave's founder and CEO.
In this episode, we have a really great conversation. We're bringing back a previous guest in John Stewart, Founding and Managing Partner with MiddleGround Capital.
Enjoy.
I am really excited to be here today, not only with an incredibly thoughtful person who has a front row seat to history playing out in the global economy, but also an encore guest from Episode 65. So I'm really excited to be here with John Stewart, who is the Founding and Managing Partner of MiddleGround Capital Partners.
John, thank you for joining us.
John Stewart: Yeah, great being here. Thanks for having me.
Sean Mooney: [00:01:00] Absolutely. John and I were talking, and we thought this would be a really great opportunity to go through what John has seen, not only in this cycle, but through new cycles, which is, I think most of us will agree, has been probably the most unique five-year period in certainly my professional life, which goes back to the 90s.
And I think most people's even go back further than that. It's hard to say, is there a more strange and dynamic period filled with black swans flying left and right?
And so John and I are going to talk about what he has seen from the front row of one of the top industrial investment firms in the world, that not only spans the US, but also the globe, and what that means for today, but also how it's going to inform tomorrow.
And so John, maybe to frame our conversation, can you give us an executive summary of what we're going to talk about in terms of what you have seen and where we're going?
John Stewart: Yeah, I mean, the last few years, going back to 2020 [00:02:00] with COVID, something that we never experienced ever in the world where we had a complete shutdown of the economy.
People were ordered to stay at home and shut down complete industries. I mean, we've never had a global stoppage. We've had regional stoppages. We deal with those all the time, but a global stoppage that was fueled by the largest incentives and stimulus that we've ever seen in the economy with 11 plus trillion dollars of stimulus going into the economy, over 5 trillion of that in the US alone, is unprecedented.
And then the swing that we saw in PMI, which is an indicator that I track very closely, being a industrial investor, which is the Purchasing Manager Index, we had the largest swing from peak-to-trough since the Korean War [00:03:00] in North America, and the largest peak-to-trough ever in PMI in Europe. And you mentioned the global financial crisis, which people are very familiar with, but the peak-to-trough there was only 19.8 points, and ours was 23.2 in the US and 30.6 in Europe.
So huge differences that have caused like a complete set of challenges that nobody was ready for when it comes to the supply chain and how much disruption it caused to the supply chain globally.
Sean Mooney: It's been singular in my mind, as you point out, and I always think, I grew up in Texas, so I only know how to speak metaphorically and can't speak like a human.
But it's just like, I feel like we've been living in a bumper car arena where you get going, and then crash, you stop. And then you get going again, and then something hits you from the side, and then you hit it in reverse, and then you swing around and then smash. And more and more it seems like I'm finding maybe an open lane to get around and go [00:04:00] so I can go crack my younger brother or something with a cart.
But it's been like a nonstop series of these stops and starts. And as we've had our conversations, I think you probably more elegantly described it as like a bullwhip economy where it's just like getting going and cracking. And so can you talk about, a little bit more about what you saw, as you pointed out, COVID comes and then you've had these kind of like massive swings.
What did you see in real life living through that, not only as a seasoned investor and business operator, but also a manager of a portfolio?
John Stewart: I think we experienced what everybody did. Pre-COVID, let's say we had inventories at normal levels and you had cost at X for your input prices, and then COVID happens, the economy slams to a standstill.
People are paid an incentive to stay home and work. There's a supplement to unemployment that was six hundred dollars a week, which a lot of people don't realize when you're talking about people [00:05:00] collecting unemployment, the entry-level wages are around fifteen dollars an hour. Well, six hundred dollars supplement a week on top of your regular unemployment, that's fifteen dollars an hour on top of what you were already getting.
So there was this massive amount of support for people not being able to work, and people are stuck at home, and they start consuming. If you can remember, like there were times we only could get two rolls of toilet paper when we went to the grocery store during COVID. Like something you would never like even like think is even like possible to happen.
So the supply chain gets completely disrupted. All the inventory, it gets consumed, so demand erupts. All of the normal priced inventory gets consumed, and now nobody's at work, and you need to resupply the supply chain with products, and the stimulus is going in, and then you start to see input prices start going up.
You have to pay higher wages [00:06:00] to get people to come back to work, and you start to see the inventories start to rebuild, but now they're rebuilding with higher cost inventory. And so we have this term now that I don't remember using this in thirty-plus years of manufacturing before this, this destocking situation.
So we build up this inventory where people are manufacturing. They finally get people back to work, but higher prices, higher input prices, higher labor costs. They start building inventory. Net costs increase, inflate by twenty-four percent, and now you have this inventory that's twenty-four percent higher for you to produce, and then demand drops like a rock.
And so now everybody's stuck with all of this inventory at higher prices, and then prices start dropping on raw material inputs and [00:07:00] everything except for labor. The bottom drops out of the demand now that everybody's back to work, and this is like the start of the bullwhip process, and then this breaks the supply chain.
I mean, it literally broke the supply chain as the peak-to-trough collapses of all of this inventory. And then the problem that we have is there's eleven trillion dollars of stimulus that go into the economy, five trillion dollars in the US. And of that, we can track about a trillion of it into public industrials just because that data is like available and in their inventories.
And because they can't sell the products at those higher prices because the demand has dropped, $500 billion is written off the balance sheet of those public companies to right-size the cost structure of the inventory. And so half of the stimulus is absorbed on the balance sheet of [00:08:00] these companies by write-offs, and then we're left at the end of the day with this de-stocking phenomenon where people have too much inventory in their stores.
People aren't pulling the inventory, and then you finally get costs normalized in the inventory. And net-net, it's still 24% higher than it was pre-COVID for the same products, and yet people don't want to say that we've had inflation. But when you look at what's actually happening, everything's more expensive to manufacture.
You can't go back once you increase labor costs for employees, and we're in this whipsaw. And it felt like it. I mean, I started my firm in 2019 and raised my first fund in August 2019, and then I had five portfolio companies. We went into COVID, and I tell my investors now after raising fund three, I'm like, "If I knew what was going to happen, I don't know that I would have started my own firm."
Been like the worst time [00:09:00] ever to go out and try to raise capital for an industrial fund. And then interest rates started rising, with the stimulus going into the economy, and it's just been challenge after challenge. And then we get started on regional disruption, and we get this nationalist policy of trying to move manufacturing back to North America that's now giving us really unprecedented volumes and productivity gains that we need in order to just, to keep up with what's going on.
So it's been a crazy time.
Sean Mooney: Hey, as a quick interlude, this is Sean here. Wanted to address one quick question that we regularly get. We often get people who show up at our website, call our account executives. They say, "Hey, I'm not private equity. Can I still use BluWave to get connected with resources?"
And the short answer is: yes. Even though we're mostly and largely used by hundreds of private equity firms, thousands of their portfolio company leaders, every day we get calls from everyday top proactive business leaders at public [00:10:00] companies, independent companies, family companies. So absolutely, you can use us as well.
If you want to use the exact same resources that are trusted and being deployed and perfectly calibrated for your business needs, give us a call, visit our website at Bluwave.net. Thanks.
Back to the episode.
Crazy is exactly right. It's, as you think about it, and we'll talk in a second, I want to get your opinion on how this compares to 2008. But even in the more current time, you talk about COVID, and then you've got a stimulus-driven kind of craze, which goes from a ground-stop, zero miles per hour, to 1,000 miles per hour, and then things start normalizing again perhaps a little bit after they take their pain and then raise the rates and everything grinds slower.
And then we have a tariff policy that then causes everyone to reorient all your global supply chains again. Now you have severe dislocation in a petrochemical [00:11:00] economy in the Middle East with some of the key straits in the world all blocked. And so it's just the hits keep on coming, right?
John Stewart: It's the new normal.
Everybody's like, "Oh, well, if we get through this period of time..." I'm like, "Well, no, there's always something." There's never a time when it's just calm. We used to think the UAW going on strike at one of the factories was, like, disruptive to the economy. Now that's like a drop in the bucket compared to the stuff that we deal with now.
We've seen stuff that's unprecedented. I mean, we've seen that the European Union, for example, that had spent a lot of time deindustrializing Western Europe into Eastern Europe and North Africa, and now you're seeing that individual countries are wanting to preserve their own capacity. They don't even rely on member states in the EU.
Like, Sweden is trying to protect critical infrastructure for themself, and the UK and with Brexit, all these things, that if you'd have told somebody before 2020 these things that were going to [00:12:00] happen, people would've thought you were crazy.
Sean Mooney: And we'll get into that later, but I think, even as you think about if we go back even further than 2008, I'll be candid, and this is politically agnostic: I think we all made a big mistake when everyone started moving things overseas through the lens of Economics 101. We're all going to do better for this, and I think we all did benefit immensely. And I started investing in China in 2001, where we started moving our plants over. In retrospect, though, I think, and this will inform maybe some of our later conversation, we'll dig into this, I think we made some mistakes in terms of not understanding the strategic relevance of having some of our means of production here, and that's, maybe that's going to inform what's going to happen later.
Before we go into that, why don't we go just a little bit more recent. I think everyone loves to compare things. It's part of the way our minds have evolved to work. And there's this notion that this time is tough, but 2008, the great financial crisis, [00:13:00] that was the hard times. And so how does something like this compare to a 2008 when people admittedly are like, "Oh, is there going to be cash in the ATM machine on Monday?"
John Stewart: Yeah.
When you look at it from a production standpoint, this has been substantially more challenging than what we saw during the global financial crisis. I had just left Toyota in 2007 to go into private equity. And so, I don't know, every time I make a career change, something devastating happens in the economy, so maybe I should just stay doing what I'm doing.
But we went through that challenge. That was interesting because during the global financial crisis, there were like whole like business categories and financing segments that still haven't recovered today. For example, like cars and boat sales where they have these financing lines for the dealer inventory, that still never recovered from the global financial crisis.
There's [00:14:00] still pockets of liquidity that people got burned in that just never came back. One of the things that was interesting is during the global financial crisis, you saw a lot of companies that typically would have found themself in like a distressed situation with a balance sheet challenge, but the banks gave a lot of people a lot of leeway because it was so broad-based.
And then by the time the companies that were truly like needed to be restructured, all the value had been destroyed, the customer relationships, the supplier relationships, and so you just saw businesses disappear. That was definitely challenging to climb back out of. And again, a lot of economic stimulus with interest rates.
And I think, like, people prior to 2009 that, maybe of mine and your age, we can remember like interest rates of 8 to 9, 10% when you would buy a home. And then it became normal that 2% was mortgage rates, [00:15:00] and then they creep up to what they are today and people like freak out. But we saw a lot more challenge before.
So the global financial crisis had its own set of challenges. But for me, this was more challenging because of the global nature of the COVID pandemic, and the health concerns that at the time, I think people rightly had. That shut everything down and kept people from being in contact with one another.
And again, like it happened on a global basis. And so it had much more severe of an impact overall because of the same scenarios playing out. Usually, like if you have something going on in North America, your European business unit is not having the same challenges. We had those challenges everywhere.
And to your point, the thing that really changed was the supply chain disruption, and it made people rethink their long supply chains, where they had moved to China [00:16:00] and other Asian countries in the late 1990s, early 2000, when everybody thought that's what we needed to be doing, and nobody had really taken a look at their domestic supply chain.
And I think people wanted more surety. You had tariffs with, from the first Trump presidency that were in effect as well. So some of this policy that's going on today started back then. I think people really started re-examining, and then when they brought the products back to North America and started manufacturing them, they realized something, and that's that the Chinese economy has improved tremendously from 1990 just for their own consumption, and there's been a lot of appreciation in costs.
And at the end of the day, I think that they saw that the cost difference when you've looked at the overall supply chain, it wasn't as great as it once was back in the 90s and early 2000 to outsource your manufacturing [00:17:00] to what we thought were these low-cost countries. And even though the labor rates are much less than they are in North America, when you factor in putting all that inventory on the water, and the lead times and everything else with it, and then the tariffs and the economic risk, people have stayed in North America with their manufacturing and stayed locally.
And we've seen it return to North America and Western Europe alike.
Sean Mooney: Hey, Karma School listeners, this is Sean with a quick aside.
Virtually every day, I'm having conversations with private equity firm professionals and business operators, and we're talking about the same exact thing: where and how do we actually start with AI?
The answer is, you start with people who have already done it successfully for others. This is exactly what BluWave does. We have built a one-of-one, invitation-only network of trusted AI enablement providers that top private equity firms are using right now to create real value. Private equity-grade quality, pre-vetted by BluWave, ready to go at a moment's notice.[00:18:00]
And they're not just for PE. Whether you're a PE professional or an operating company CEO, go to Bluwave.net. That's B-L-U-W-A-V-E. We'll get you to the right resources so you can start on your AI journey right now.
History might not repeat itself, but it certainly rhymes, right? And so like you said, 6% for your mortgage was normal. It actually was normal. And then if I go to my parents, they would say that was cheap.
John Stewart: Yeah, 10%.
Sean Mooney: Yeah. But so much of this came, if you go back to the GFC, in some ways we were fortunate.
We had as the chairman of the Fed, Ben Bernanke, who was one of the world's top experts on the Great Depression. He was maybe the right person at the right time, and he goes, "Here's how we get through this. We are going to flood the banks and the capital markets with liquidity that will keep the run on the banks from happening."
And there was nearly a run on the banks, because [00:19:00] I remember there's that one weekend where everyone had their friend at the Fed, and they're like, "We're not sure if there's going to be cash in the ATMs. And flooded the market got the banks to ease off and not call in loans. And then we went through this great prosperous time, in part because they never took their foot off the gas.
It's like they kept the rates at near zero. In some ways, but I think policymakers can't help themselves, because that causes a great market. But as I remember, and you recall this, going into 2019 heading into 2020 before COVID, most people were planning on a recession. They were raising rates to slow things down, and the hangover was coming from the party over the last decade.
And they're like, "We're going to go through a normal recession." And then COVID came, and what did they do? They dusted off the playbook, and they just tripled down on liquidity. And that caused all of these whipsaws that you've talked about, the likes of which most of us have never seen in our lives.
John Stewart: The stimulus that went in effect from [00:20:00] 2020 through 2022 was 12% of GDP. That $5.2 trillion in the US, $2.3 trillion in Europe, a trillion dollars in China, Japan a trillion dollars, it was unprecedented. I mean, some of that money's still just now being spent from some of the programs that were put in place.
Think about it. I mean, what, we have $40 trillion of debt today? And $5 trillion of that happened in an 18-month period of time? It's completely unprecedented. You talk about foot on the gas, that's literally just throwing money at the problem.
Sean Mooney: And then here's the problem. And once again, I don't view this through the lens of any kind of political persuasion. We're Michael Jordan. We sell shoes to both sides, right?
But if you were to take 2019 government spending versus today's tax base, we would be in surplus right now. And once again, it's like the same lesson we didn't learn in 2008, the same lesson in [00:21:00] 2020. We just didn't take our foot off the gas and go back to normal.
And that's causing, as you I think so eloquently said, these kind of whipsaw effects that go through. And we'll talk about, it seems to be like there's some things that are setting up for what will be a good run, and a more stable run, as these these shocks have worked their way through and worked their way through.
It still doesn't make it easy in the meantime. I think we talked about 2008. It was really tough, but you didn't have a shutdown of an entire global supply chain. And arguably we had almost like a big one and then a little one with the tariff kind of reset across the globe.
Let's maybe bring it back to today, John. Where are we now? We're taking our medicine on the inflation. We're having to keep rates high. We still have work to do on that. We've done some other kind of global things that you can share. What does the data say now? Like, we've gone through these latest couple shocks. What's the state of the global manufacturing world today?
John Stewart: The recovery that has [00:22:00] started post-COVID is very recent, and it's Q1 of 2026 Is the first time that the PMI has moved positive in both North America and Europe. In Europe, it was 44 months of contraction, and 20-plus months in North America. In Q1 of 2026, we're finally starting to see positive PMI.
The steam is picking up from that. That is basically going out and talking to purchasing managers of industrial companies and asking, "Are you going to buy more in the upcoming period than you did before?" And when that number gets above 50, means that most people are going to be buying more, to simplify that metric, and that's a recent phenomenon.
So we saw a protracted period of time where there was contraction, and now you're seeing this massive expansion coming right off [00:23:00] the tail of last year, where we had the President that announced Liberation Day, and the whole M&A market shut down for six months last year because people didn't understand what was going to happen with the tariffs from day to day, from week to week, and month to month.
Sean Mooney: I think it's a great point. I remember going through the period that you were talking about. One of the things we're lucky is we get to work with firms like yours, and we get to see everything that's going on in our data. And then, same thing, I was looking at PMI, and I was like, "Everyone's saying we're not in recession."
Maybe business services and tech wasn't in a recession, but industrial sure was. It's like, no one's talking about this, but a large part of the global economy's in recession. But just because the balance of GDP was above 0%, a big portion of that was negative.
John Stewart: Semiconductor AI is where you've seen the real massive growth.
It's in the news every day about the data centers and just, it's kind of crazy the amount of volume [00:24:00] that you're seeing pour into the industrial economy globally again. Aerospace and defense with the wars and the increase in defense spending in Europe.
I'm, like, apolitical. You have to be when you're an investor and you raise money and capital. But before the President challenged Europe and NATO on spending, there were a handful of them, I think less than nine, that were spending 2% of GDP on defense, and now all of them do, and now they're trying to get to 5% GDP. I mean, just think about, like, how much spending that has been.
A good example: we own a company, and it's not an aerospace and defense business. This company makes transmissions for motorsport, and so we make transmissions for IndyCar, NASCAR, F1, and hypercars, and those types of products, so really sophisticated machining components and products. And last year, 5% of the quote log of just the quotes that [00:25:00] came in, 5% were aerospace and defense related.
This year, 35% are. That's the level of difference. And so semiconductor, AI, aerospace defense, industry 4.0, like automation, because that's the other problem that we have in industrial economy, is young people today don't want to work in a plant, in a factory. Who wants to work third shift at a factory doing manual labor? People don't want to do that. And so automating these factories is a big challenge.
I mean, most of the businesses-- we own over 200 facilities all over the world. They're using technology from pre-1970 on average. And in some cases, I have some display pieces in our office that investors think are like antiques, and they came right out of plants.
And so there's a massive move to try to automate and move to efficiency in these facilities with advanced manufacturing of automation. And then infrastructure spending fueled by the TARP spending that was a part of the COVID relief [00:26:00] package. And then we saw, again, something else that happened during COVID that we didn't see before, is people started to really push out elective surgeries, and this caused a massive impact in the med-tech space.
Those five areas, we've seen recovery, but then, like you talked about, general industrial is still, over 2024 to '26, its overall trend has been negative 0.5%. Then when you look at automotive, that is an area that we always hear about, because it's such a big driver of the economy. But you're talking 2% to 3% growth from '24 to '26.
But then when you start looking out, going forward on all of these different end markets, you're seeing 6% to 16% growth from '26 to '28. And we're seeing that real time, beginning in Q1 of this year.
Sean Mooney: And so how much of this is true cyclical, right? Where it's [00:27:00] a natural coming out of a cycle. As people forgot, when you and I were coming up, cycles would happen every five to eight years like clockwork.
And then since 2009, we went to 2022, essentially, until there was another cycle. So how much of this is a natural cycle? And then how much of it is being supported by policy regarding the strategic mandate really to own the means of production? And then, how much of this would you say is also policies like incentivizing capital expenditures with tax incentives, or is it all of the above?
John Stewart: Investors always tell me all the time, "Well, we don't like to invest in cyclical businesses." Well then you're not an investor, because since 1901 we've had 27 cycles in the U.S. To your point, every five years there's a cycle. Now, we saw that tremendously stabilize once the U.S. got off the gold standard and went to the current kind of monetary policy, and it actually did [00:28:00] stabilize the cycles that we saw from like 1975 through current have not had the depths of the previous cycles.
And so, from that part it was achieved, but at a tremendous cost, which we can talk about more in a minute with what's going on with the debt in this country versus the S&P 500. I mean, I did an analysis on it from 1990 to today, and it's a .98 correlation, which is a near perfect correlation of debt to the value in the S&P 500.
So what does that say for public market investing? The US government has to have their foot on the gas, has to continue to put liquidity into the market, has to continue to do those things. Otherwise you're going to see a collapse in the public markets, which I think everybody that has ever done any type of historical analysis would say that the public markets are completely dislocated from actual value anymore.
So going back to your question of, [00:29:00] like, how much of this is just pure cyclicality, I think there's a piece of it that is, but I think we're still feeling the repercussions of this bullwhip where this $11 trillion went into the economy, and that's actually what really created this need to increase interest rates.
Because with all of that stimulus going into the economy, all these government dollars going into these programs, something had to be done to cool it off. And so you see about a 12 to 18-month lag from the peak of the stimulus going in till where the Fed started increasing interest rates during that July 2022 to July of 2023.
What people need to understand is what's happening, I don't think this is natural. I think this is engineered, and not like anybody did it negatively, but it's engineered. It's an engineered response to COVID and what was [00:30:00] happening in the economy. And when you throw $11 trillion in the global economy in a 12 to 18-month period of time, this is kind of the result of what you see.
And then you throw in the protectionist policy in North America with trying to get parity with tariffs with other countries.
And then in Europe, again, they've been destabilized because of the war in Ukraine. When the war started, remember all of the mass migration that was going on and people were literally staying at other people's houses.
Europe thought they were safe, and then all of a sudden, their neighbor gets... Europe and the United States are, if you look at the size, are similar. It's kind of, if you were living in Colorado and Florida got invaded, right? That's like the impact of the war in Ukraine. It really hit home in Europe, and people thought it was safe to manufacture products in North Africa and Eastern Europe, [00:31:00] and all of a sudden you see everybody trying to push back into Western Europe, and Western Europe's been deindustrialized.
They don't have the infrastructure. We did a study with one of our third-party commercial groups, and it's impossible for the EU to spend 5% of GDP on defense. They need to spend 2.5% over the next five years just to re-industrialize their countries so that they can actually make the products that they need to make, because they don't have the capability.
Sean Mooney: As I'm listening to you speak here, there are huge strategic shifts, right? There are strategic re-industrialization occurring in the US and Europe for a variety of reasons, not only because of supporting home industries, but I think also as national security. There's a pendulum that's swinging back from some of the economic policies that are going beyond that.
You also have kind of generational trends going on with semiconductors and AI that are supporting this. You've got re-militarization [00:32:00] occurring across the globe as there's global rivals, and then you have tax policies that are also supporting this further, in some ways probably to make it happen so that it has to happen, right, putting incentives and penalties, if you will.
What does that mean for the industrial investor in the US? What kind of opportunities does that set the stage for?
John Stewart: Well, both in the US and in Europe, right? I mean, Europe, it's kind of unprecedented opportunity for investment. We haven't seen this much industrialization in Western Europe since World War II, and that was because the infrastructure had been destroyed.
And so, it's a massive, opportunity. When you look at private equity funds, and you look at, like, when their raised peak-to-trough from a PMI perspective, there's almost 20% difference on returns. When you're in a vintage fund that was raised at the trough, of course it's investing [00:33:00] across kind of a recovery phase, and that's exactly what we're in right now.
And we see that when you look at the investments that have been made in the last 12 months or 18 months compared to the ones that were made three years ago, during the COVID periods, from 2020 through 2023, during that period of time, the performance of those businesses has been much better, and the performance of those funds are going to be much better for investors.
And the M&A markets basically came to a standstill. The interest rates drove a lot of that because, of course, what are the drivers of M&A from financial sponsors? Well, it's debt. That's how we value businesses. It's how much debt that you can get on a business because that's a key component of what goes on in the economy.
So the rates were high, and then we had tax policy that interest was not tax-deductible, which directly penalized private equity firms owning [00:34:00] companies. That consumes a lot of cash flow when you think about the corporate tax rate. And then we had bonus depreciation that was put in as a part of the stimulus for COVID, where you could fully depreciate assets in year one in order for people to buy and invest in capital.
That was tailing off and had dropped down to where you only could bonus depreciate up to 40%. And then when the administration implemented the Big Beautiful Bill and returned those two items, that unlocked the whole M&A market. The deal flow going into the first quarter that prior 18 to 24 months, really slow.
And from that point on, I mean, we're just super busy with a lot of really good deals that private equity firms, owner-operators, who both have different reasons they're selling. Private equity firms are selling because they're older vintage funds that they didn't have a market to sell, and now they're trying to get out of those, and they have new funds, and they have [00:35:00] new capital to deploy.
And then you have owner-operators where you would think "Why are they getting out when the economy is booming?" Well, they have to invest in the working capital and the growth. Working capital comes down when there's a trough, and so you can actually generate cash as the working capital comes down and demand comes down.
When demand expands, and everybody thinks that's fantastic, well, these small businesses, they have to consume a lot of working capital, because most of them, their customers have better terms with them than they do their vendors, so it requires a lot of working capital. And you find a lot of owner-operators, say you're a 65-year-old owner-operator, and you're going like, "Okay, well, do I really want to invest this money in these opportunities that I'm seeing right now? Because I'm going to have to probably stay in this business another 10 years in order to recoup that investment." And a lot of them are saying no, and, they're taking those businesses to market. So the increase in owner-operator businesses that we're seeing is pretty dramatic.
Sean Mooney: I think those are great points.
And one of the [00:36:00] things that, you know, as I'm listening to you speak here, John, it's: no one really understood when we were in the recession that we were in a recession. And now a lot of people have been saying, "Oh, it's..." And they're all fatigued. But as we all know, you and I have seen a number of cycles, it might be darkest right before dawn, but then the sun comes up, and that usually creates some opportunity.
How big of an investing opportunity are we in right now, given where we are in the curve?
John Stewart: We've never seen an opportunity like this before. The demand that sits in front of our companies is bigger than it's ever been before. The challenges that the companies face where we need investment in these mid-market companies, there's a lot of industrialization that goes outside of the S&P 500, the Dow Jones, these public companies.
There's a lot more middle-market companies that are responsible for producing a lot of these products, and on average, they have never modernized their facilities. They're [00:37:00] using production methods from pre-1970. I get investors all the time asking about AI disruption in our companies. Well, isn't it possible to make lights out manufacturing for most things?
I'm like, "Yeah, that's been around for 40 years." People aren't investing that level of capital into these companies. That's not the first challenge. The first challenge is to get them to 1980 technology. There's a huge investment need in these companies that without the investment in automation in factories, both in North America and Western Europe, the companies cannot produce the demand for products today and going forward.
They don't have the capacity. So there's a massive investment necessary in the automation of these factories in order to be able to get more capacity out of these plants to keep up with the rising demand.
Sean Mooney: And how much has the industry now helped with the policy [00:38:00] of 100% bonus depreciation? And for our listeners, if you're not familiar with that, essentially what the federal government is saying is, usually with an asset you buy, you get a tax benefit over the usable life of the asset.
So it could be three, four, five, six, seven years. Now they're saying, "You buy it, you get all the... take all that tax in the first year."
How much does that help but make these kind of investments?
John Stewart: That's permanent now. It's in law. Oh, it's phenomenal. Again, you do an automation project and it costs you $2 million.
Okay, well you can deduct that $2 million off your net income, and it's like the federal government is paying 25 to 35%, just depending on your tax situation. They're contributing that portion of it, so it encourages you to spend. And what does that do? That drives demand.
And the same thing goes for aviation. Companies need to update their fleets in the commercial aviation market. Okay, well they can spend [00:39:00] that money, they can write it all off, and they get the tax benefit for doing that. The same thing with private aviation. And so it really does spark consumption. So capital equipment manufacturers, companies that are doing automation.
We built our own automation team inside of our private equity firm because we can't get companies to automate our factories, because they have 18, 24-month lead times, because the demand's so high. It's a different challenge than we had when the bottom fell out of demand and you were stuck with all this high-priced inventory.
But now we can see the demand, and it's all there, and it's capable of being executed. But these companies, they need massive amount of investment and working capital, which some of their current owner operators who don't use leverage are going to be funding that dollar for dollar, and that's a tall ask depending on, like, where they are in their personal career and their personal financial goals.
You've got to imagine that most owner operators, [00:40:00] 100% of their net worth or their family's net worth is tied up in one asset. That makes people unsure. And so that's a catalyst for people to seek to sell their businesses. And it's just a massive opportunity that needs investment, and it's a perfect opportunity for investors to make investments in this space. And on the other side of things, industrial manufacturing, even though it's capable, you can do stuff lights out.
Like I said, we're using technology that's fifty years, sixty years old. And AI and the disruption it's going to have on the economy and on jobs, people are looking at industrial companies as a haven now, because the software-as-a-service business model is over. I mean, five years from now, people don't realize that you're not going to be subscribing to Microsoft Windows.
You're not going to be using Excel and Word, and you're not going to be paying that model of where they stop selling you software and they start charging you a [00:41:00] license fee. That whole thing's going away. There's already no operating system AI models out there. They don't need Excel. They can make their own spreadsheet.
That's all going to go away. Investors are looking at okay, we were over-focused on tech and a lot of it was software related, and there's only so many options to go into actual AI companies and data centers and chip technology. And so people are looking for other opportunities. And so, when you have more capital going into a space, so more people are interested in investing in it, demand's going up and you have more people willing to sell their assets, you're seeing valuations start to grow on these assets and something that we have not really seen in some time.
And for investors, especially in private markets, when you look at what's happened, like you mentioned, post-COVID from 2012 to 2017, there was an [00:42:00] overflow of cash. So the investors were getting more cash in than they were committing each year. And then from 2017 through 2025, that's been a net deficit.
They've been putting more money out than they've been net receiving. And so their... a lot of their value is unrealized, and a lot of the dry powder that they have, it's not really there, because they don't have the liquidity. That's how the investors fund future capital commitment based on liquidity. And we're just starting to see that phenomenon starting to change as well.
And so right as all of this is happening with a 12-month lag, now all of a sudden you're starting to see a completely different environment where there's a lot more capital now competing to go in to the same set of opportunities.
Sean Mooney: What you said really strikes home. Anyone who [00:43:00] studies cycles, and I think if you've been in the investing business, you study them over time.
And like you said, like if you're in the investing business, you invest in cycles. How many times has the Fed said there's no more, any more cycles, and then they happen again, right? We're coming into that next part of the good side of the curve here. Probably have been in it actually for a little bit already.
The funds that are already in those places tend to have done well based on the studies I've done. The other thing that I think is pretty interesting about this whole thing, as I hear you play it out, John, is, it's not just the investors and it's the owners, but the jobs it creates. I've had three conversations with peers of ours whose kids would 99% all have gone to college and gotten some sort of, you name the degree.
In those three conversations, each of them said they have one of their kids going into the trades. "I'm going to be an electrician. I'm going to be a plumber. I'm going to go into this construction field." Whereas the idea of building and making things again is becoming back in vogue, as not only the means of production comes back, but also the people who can do it and make [00:44:00] it happen is getting re-attracted to that.
John Stewart: That's fantastic.
The problem is that the demand is stronger than the people coming into the industry, and these are different jobs now. So when in an automated factory, you're not standing unloading and loading a machine, you're running automated cells that are five or six robots that are loading and unloading different machines. And there's a whole technology opportunity that can be interesting for people.
But I enjoy trying to figure out the puzzle pieces. Like you said, there's all these different trends and these different end markets and different economic situations, and these curve balls that we get with the geopolitical climate today.
Last year was, like, insane. When else have we seen anything like that, where all these tariffs are announced, people are going to the Supreme Court to try to see if things can be upheld, and it's crazy craziness to deal with [00:45:00] all of these things. And I don't think that average people actually understand what's going on.
The President, I'm not one political party or the other, but he keeps mentioning that he's just going after parity. Well, that's because every other country charges us a tariff for all of our products. We're just saying, "Okay, if you charge us 30%, we're going to charge you 30%," trying to get like equality on trade.
From a manufacturing standpoint, I don't think there's a lot of people in manufacturing that are not a fan of the policy of defending North American jobs. I mean, back in the early '80s when I started my career, I mean, look at what happened to the automotive industry. People forget it wasn't three, four years ago that General Motors announced like shutting down nine facilities in North America because all the products were made in Mexico and Canada.
Well, what are people doing now that they've got these tariffs? And it may not be on autos, they may have got an exclusion because of their lobbyists, but the raw materials and these different products. [00:46:00] So you're seeing a resurgence of manufacturing opportunities come back, and finding the right assets that are aligned to it is really interesting.
Sean Mooney: This has been a very timely conversation, a historic conversation given where we are in the cycle. And I think it very appropriately points out that when people, when they get exhausted, they throw in their cards at the exact time they should play the hand. And so I think there's a lot of opportunities coming here.
If you were to give a piece of advice to an operator, a family business owner in the industrial space, what might be a piece of advice that you would say, "Here's how you play the hand right now"?
John Stewart: I would tell every operator: if you're not investing in modernizing and automating your plant, you may not be around five years from now.
The people that are going to thrive are the people that are modernizing and automating the plant. That's not trying to eliminate jobs. Again, you can raise wages, and this is something that we [00:47:00] focused on across our portfolio. You're actually raising wages of the people that actually work in the companies because, again, you have four people unloading and loading machines, and you can put robots in or cobots in for 25, $35,000 to unload and load the machines, and now you have one person overseeing four machines.
Well, you can pay that person, instead of paying them $15 an hour, you can pay them $30 an hour, and you can still put money in your pocket from an efficiency standpoint, and that's the only way that you're going to be able to meet the demand. It's amazing to me how in Western Europe and in North America, I think the average person would be truly amazed at how antiquated the technology is in a lot of these businesses.
And so, you've got to have a strategy for automation and how you're going to execute it. It's not about just spending money. Some of these automation projects can be very expensive and very difficult to justify. And so [00:48:00] with Toyota, we always focused on simple automation. So, there's a way to do it cost efficient, but if you don't do it, you're going to be challenged to be able to meet the demand that you need to.
Every business owner, any of us, you own your own business, I own my own business, we're entrepreneurs, every incremental dollar that you invest in your business is precious. And so trying to figure out where that incremental dollar goes, is it going to just go for inventory, for some increase in orders, some new customer, or is it going to be in plant automation?
Sean Mooney: I think it's great advice, and I think it's spot on in terms of, this is a great time to be playing the game of business in the industrial world, but you still have to play chess, not checkers. The board is different than it was five years ago, which was different from the way five years ago. So if you're going to play to win, you've got to look a few moves ahead, and that's going to be automation.
That's going to be adopting tools like AI in places of your business, and it's going to be looking to where the world is going to be versus where it was. It doesn't mean it's going to be easy, but [00:49:00] those who play the game well are going to do probably quite nicely.
John Stewart: Yeah. I mean, for example, you mentioned AI. I don't do one work stream now without AI.
Everything I do, if you look at my computer screen, I've got eight different screens up right now with eight different projects being worked on with AI. It's going to be devastatingly impactful for financial services businesses, for services companies, for software businesses. We've not even seen a drop in the bucket of the impact that it's going to have on these businesses.
And so, investors are looking for: where is a place that there's still an opportunity to invest in technology to create growth and expansion? And industrials falls right into that bucket.
Sean Mooney: I'll give you some insight into what we're seeing. The fastest growing area that we're getting used by other PE firms is AI.
It's growing exponentially. One in three of the projects that we get demand for are for bringing AI to industrial companies. [00:50:00] And I think now I understand it actually a little bit better as we've been talking, and it's not because it's existentially risky. It's helping modernize companies that maybe have not modernized in a couple decades, and bring them up to where they should be faster at a much higher ROI, and getting them to where they should be.
Whereas, they probably lived in the past a little bit too long.
John Stewart: The average company we buy, they have no ERP system. They're using QuickBooks, or they're using a system and it's 15 years old. And they don't have a CRM. You don't need a CRM anymore, I'm sorry, Salesforce, and, these other companies, you don't need it anymore.
If you have your data, then you can create all the front end with AI. And so, the first step we had, like all of our companies, like we said, okay, because they didn't have a strategy, and we help them to think about what they're doing. And the first thing is just get a Claude membership and just start trying to use it.
Well, one of our companies, they built their own CRM system with Claude, and [00:51:00] don't have to have a third-party CRM system. And so what you're going to see is you're going to see the technology become more accessible, because you just tell it what you need, and it builds what you need and your capability.
The challenge is people trusting AI with their data. That's been a challenge that we've seen. People are like, "Oh, what's Claude doing with my data?" And, rightfully so, there's some concerns. It's just new challenges that we have to figure out. But I tell every one of my employees, "If you don't embrace AI and how you can use it to transform your job, your job's in jeopardy."
If you think, "I don't have to use this tool," to me it's the most disruptive technology that I've seen in my lifetime.
Sean Mooney: Yeah, I agree with that. As you've pointed out, business is never easy. Always has been, always will be, and if it were easy, everyone would be a business builder.
I think this has been a great conversation. It's been encouraging. I think the world is full of opportunity if you have the audacity to run towards it. [00:52:00] It's nice to have a tailwind now behind us instead of some of the ones that were coming right into our face a few years ago.
So John, thank you so much for joining us. This has been a fantastic episode where I've learned a ton of things with pages of notes here that I'm going to go wax poetic with our team after this.
But I want to thank you for coming here and sharing what you've seen in, not only in terms of where we've come, but also where we're going.
John Stewart: Yeah, no, look, it's exciting, and I know change is always unnerving for people, but we've got to deal with different things now. And I wasn't an AI expert 12 months ago, but I learned a lot about it and just jumped in and tried to learn these things.
And we have a lot of challenges facing us. But that's one of the good things about American workers is we've always responded to the challenges that are out there. That's part of the fun of doing what we do, is trying to figure things out like a puzzle.
Sean Mooney: 100%. Let's go play the board, and play to win.[00:53:00]
That's all we have for today. Special thanks to John for joining. If you'd like to learn more about John Stewart and MiddleGround Capital, please see the episode notes for links.
Please continue to look for the Karma School of Business podcast anywhere you find your favorite podcasts. We truly appreciate your support.
If you like what you hear, please follow, five-star rate, review, and share. It's a free way to support the show, and it really helps us when you do this, so thank you in advance. In the meantime, if you want to be connected with the world's best-in-class private equity-grade professional service providers, independent consultants, interim executives, AI advisors, that are deployed and trusted by the very best business builders in the world, including many hundreds of the world's top PE firms and thousands of portfolio companies, and you can do the same whether or not you're in the PE world, give us a call or visit our website at Bluwave.net, and we'll support your success.
Onward.
The views and opinions expressed in this program are those of the individuals presenting and do not necessarily reflect the views or positions of any other persons or entities, including those referenced herein. [00:54:00] No representations, warranties, financial, legal, tax, or other advice are made herein.
Consult your advisors regarding any topics discussed during this episode.
Karma School of Business
BluWave Founder & CEO Sean Mooney hosts the Private Equity Karma School of Business Podcast. BluWave is the business builders’ network for private equity grade due diligence and value creation needs.
Disclaimers
*“This document does not constitute advice or a recommendation or offer to sell or a solicitation to deal in any security or financial product. It is provided for information purposes only and on the understanding that the recipient has sufficient knowledge and experience to be able to understand and make their own evaluation of the proposals and services described herein, any risks associated therewith and any related legal, tax, accounting or other material considerations. To the extent that the reader has any questions regarding the applicability of any specific issue discussed above to their specific portfolio or situation, prospective investors are encouraged to contact MiddleGround or consult with the professional advisor of their choosing.”
**“Except where otherwise indicated, the information contained in this presentation is based on matters as they exist as of the date of preparation of such material and not as of the date of distribution or any future date. Recipients should not rely on this material in making any future investment decision.” “Certain information contained herein constitutes “forward-looking statements,” which can be identified by the use of forward-looking terminology such as “may,” “will,” “should,” “expect,” “anticipate,” “project,” “estimate,” “intend,” “continue,” or “believe,” or the negatives thereof or other variations thereon or comparable terminology. Due to various risks and uncertainties, actual events, results or actual performance may differ materially from those reflected or contemplated in such forward-looking statements. Nothing contained herein may be relied upon as a guarantee, promise, assurance or a representation as to the future.”
***“Certain information contained herein has been obtained from third party sources and such information has not been independently verified by MiddleGround. No representation, warranty, or undertaking, expressed or implied, is given to the accuracy or completeness of such information by MiddleGround or any other person. While such sources are believed to be reliable, MiddleGround does not assume any responsibility for the accuracy or completeness of such information. MiddleGround does not undertake any obligation to update the information contained herein as of any future date.”
Related Articles
Connect with
a pre-vetted
resource now
Do you need an exact-fit, PE-grade, third-party resource for your nuanced due diligence, value creation, or prep-for-sale work? We've got you covered.
To learn more or start a project, contact our client success team at 615-588-4010 or fill out the form to have us call you.

